Saturday, November 1, 2008
Coral Page Abbott
“Daylong a duet of shade and light/ Plays between these.” (Two Sisters 3-4). Thus ends the first stanza of Sylvia Plath’s poem “Two Sisters of Persephone”. Plath’s life was full of light and dark, conflicting feelings and ideas. This particular image- of shadow and sunshine, light and dark, white and black- shows up often in her poetry. Two of the most notable poems that use this imagery are “Two Sisters of Persephone” and “Wintering”. In “Two Sisters of Persephone” and “Wintering”, Plath uses light and dark to contrast fearful images with lighter, happier images that also have a malevolent side to them.
Darkness imagery is used in both poems to show fearful or disgusting things. She writes, “Black asininity. Decay. / Possession. / It is they who own me.” (17-19). Plath is obviously afraid of these objects, she does not want them to own her, but she also notes that the personified objects of darkness are “Neither cruel nor indifferent, only ignorant.” (Wintering 20-21). She realizes it is not their fault, but she is still owned mentally by this darkness. In Plath’s life, she suffered from difficult situations. The death of her father impacted her greatly, and influenced some of her better-known poems. She is more likely referring to the mental illness that she suffered from when saying “Black asininity.” Because “asinine” basically means “stupid” or “idiotic” and “black” when used in this way is sometimes used when talking about temper (i.e. “he was in a black mood and because of that, threw a chair at the wall.”) or depression (“back to black”). Plath was most likely referring to her bipolar episodes she experienced throughout her twenties, which were upsetting to her obviously. So saying that black asininity owns her and shows her inability to escape her mental illness. Another time Plath uses darkness is when she writes “In her dark wainscoted room/ The first works problems on/ A mathematical machine. Dry ticks mark time.” (Two Sisters 5-7). In this instance, darkness is shown in a negative light. It is used in association with math, an obviously unappealing subject, and gives this part a hermit-like feel. The situation is slow and sinister, “dry ticks mark time” means time is going slowly; second by second in the little room. There is a grim feeling, as if the room is inescapable. The room is wainscoted, or paneled with dark wood, almost like a cage with no opening. This shows a dislike for the virgin sisters way of life in “Two Sisters of Persephone” and how her life is actually very sad. The last quote where Plath shows the idea of darkness being sinister is “Black/ Mind against all that white.” (Wintering 32-33). This shows an evil in the bees discussed in the poem. They are sadness and fear against the background of a happy thing. In this case, Sylvia is referencing herself yet again. The bee’s evil is her mental illness. The “black mind” is her own, a black spot in a happy world. It shows her mental darkness affecting her, yet she is able to discuss it without being too concerned. In both poems, physical darkness is used to symbolize mental darkness.
Plath uses light in her poems to show things as perfect or beautiful, yet they always have a more sinister side. She wrote, “The smile of the snow is white/ It spreads itself out, a mile-long body of Meissen.” (Wintering 33-35). The white snow is perfect, and beautiful. It is smiling and kind. Meissen is a type of plaster, which is smooth and neat, and can cover everything up. However, snow is cold and potentially harmful to the bees. They “can only carry their dead” into the snow on warm days. The bees are not happy in snow, because it can kill them. Plaster may cover things up, but it is false and deceiving, like the snow to the bees. In “Two Sisters of Persephone”, Plath wrote that the outdoor sister “burns open to the suns blade”. This is in reference to sex, an experience that is generally meant to be pleasant so that people will reproduce. The sun is the brightest light there is, yet in this poem the sun is personified as a husband who seems to be raping his wife and attacking her with a “blade”. The sun provides life, yet in this instance the woman is being burned open by the sun. This use of oxymoron in reference to marriage shows Plath’s dislike for marriage. In both poems, light is used to portray things that are supposed to be good but turn out to actually be very negative.
Plath’s use of light and darkness in her poems is very important because it gives a whole new level to Plath’s poetry. The imagery gives “Two Sisters of Persephone” and “Wintering” an entirely new meaning. Plath’s use of imagery in general in her poems is sometimes subtle, or not originally seen as significant. However, once these images are acknowledged, we can better understand her work.
Percy Chan
“I have done it again. / One year in every ten / I manage it” (“Lady” 1 – 2). In many of her poems Sylvia Plath often writes about her experiences. She often uses imagery to convey her feelings and grab the audience’s attention. In Lady Lazarus and Daddy, Plath uses images of the Holocaust to portray her father, her pain, and her struggle for sanity.
During her life Sylvia was subject to many traumatic events, one of which was the death of her father. This traumatic experience led to a deep resentment and caused Plath to cling on to her memories of him. In Daddy, “Daddy I have had to kill you. / You died before I had time - - -“(“Daddy” 6-7). She expresses her ambivalence to her father’s passing, and she expresses a feeling of loathing of not having the chance to kill her father. Her feeling of loathing could be caused by her own feelings that her father had left her too quickly, and the feelings of abandonment eventually turned into contempt for his passing. Due to her father’s passing, Plath was somewhat confused at the world around her “I thought every German was you” (“Daddy” 29). In her depressed state, Plath was easily drawn to things that reminded her of her father. The Bee poems were written, with their topics about bees, a connection to her father’s last dissertation on bees. Eventually Plath decides to move on with her life, finally placing her father to rest in her mind. “Daddy, you can lie back now. / There’s a stake in your fat black heart / And the villagers never liked you” (“Daddy” 75 – 77). Besides her father, Holocaust imagery is also used to show her pain and depression.
One of the reasons Sylvia Plath wrote was to show people her feelings and pain. In her poem Daddy she shows the reader her desperation, and hints slightly at her own pain and suffering. “Of war, wars, wars” (“Daddy” 18), Sylvia puts the idea of war, which symbolizes her pain and her suffering. She uses not only the repetition of war, but the relationship between the Germans and Jews in World War II. “I began to talk like a Jew. / I think I may well be a Jew” (“Daddy” 34 – 35). She places herself as a Jew, and is made to suffer at the hands of the German, who represents her father. In this instance she shows the audience a glance at her personal life, and how much pain she feels on a daily basis. Furthermore she shows instances in which she shows her want to die. “Peel off the napkin / O my enemy” (“Lady” 10-11), Plath has shows her face bandaged in linen, to be taken off by her enemy. She feels that she needs to die, and that she can accomplish her goal by causing herself pain and suffering. “I am only thirty. / And like a cat I have nine times to die” (“Lady” 20 – 21). Plath tells the audience she seeks her death, that the next attempt will be her third. She compares herself to a cat, how she has nine lives, and nine chances to die. She seeks death but is constantly saved “So, so, Herr Doktor. / So, Herr Enemy” (“Lady” 65 – 66), she ultimately learns to despise the ones who prevent her from reaching her goal, and brands them her enemies. Her rapid fall into her third and final suicide attempt was a struggle between her sanity and her suicidal insanity.
During the period leading to her final suicide Plath wrote about her father, and the pain she felt from losing him. However we can also see a small struggle to survive in some of her poems. “And they stuck me together with glue. / And then I knew what to do” (“Daddy” 62-63), Although her recovery from her suicide attempt is used in a negative light, it still shows a hint of Plath wanting to survive and live on. “Come back in broad day / To the same place, the same face, the same brute” (“Lady” 52 – 53), coming into broad day light, it represents her awakening, from the despair she had felt. Although she ultimately falls back into despair, because she sees the same things as she did when she was in despair.
There are many things the Holocaust imagery can come to represent, from Sylvia’s father Otto Plath, Sylvia’s depression and suffering, to her struggle for life. After reading her poems, the audience can find a new appreciation for confessional poetry, which in turn adds to the literary features used by the audience. The dark imagery of the Holocaust was a suitable choice for the feelings and experiences that Plath tried to convey to her audience, and in the end she is successful in creating lasting works to be looked upon by other confessional poets.
Alex Yamamoto
“I may be a bit of a Jew” (“Daddy”, 40). Sylvia Plath’s use of Holocaust imagery is not uncommon within her poetry. It effectively highlights her dark and deathly tones by giving vivid imagery that could connect with any reader. By relating her own personal experience to that of the Jews, the amount of pain and anguish she felt is passed on to the reader. In “Daddy” and “Lady Lazarus,” Holocaust images show suffering and relationships Plath had.
Plath’s use of Holocaust imagery invokes many emotions to the reader. More specifically in both “Daddy” and “Lady Lazarus,” Plath uses it to compare her suffering to the Jews and says, “I think I may well be a Jew” (“Daddy”, 35). She describes the suffering she felt when she says, “my skin / Bright as a Nazi lampshade” (“Lazarus”, 4-5), which is an allusion to the rumor that Nazis used Jew’s skin as lampshades. However, differences exist between the poems because in “Daddy” her suffering is physical pain, while in “Lady Lazarus” her suffering is mental. When trying to show physical pain, Plath uses the most vivid image of the Holocaust, “A Jew, to Dachau, Aushwitz, Belsen” (“Daddy”, 33). By directly referring to the concentration camps where Jews were inflicted with the most horrendous pain, Plath successfully shows the pain her father and husband caused her. While for mental suffering, she says, “That melts like a shriek” (“Lazarus”, 70), which uses the fact that Jews were killed in ovens to show the pain and suffering she feels within herself. Not only do the Holocaust images show suffering, they also show relationships Plath has.
In both “Daddy” and “Lady Lazarus” she shows relationships of resent and hatred. While “Daddy” is the relationship that Plath has with her father, “Lady Lazarus” is her relationship with death. Plath shows her hatred through Nazi imagery when she says, “I have always been scared of you, / With your Luftwaffe” (“Daddy”, 41-42). By directly comparing herself to the Jews and her father to the Nazis, the amount of resent and hatred seen is paramount. These images greatly enhance the dark tone of the poem and the theme of how she hates her father. In “Lady Lazarus” it is clearly seen that she is talking about suicide when she says, “like a cat I have nine times to die” (21). However Holocaust images enhance the feeling of death when she says, “I do it [commit suicide] so it feel like hell” (46). Just like the Nazi’s brutally tortured the Jews, Plath tortured herself, but unlike most Jews Plath survived her ordeals.
Plath’s Holocaust images have caused controversy because she is comparing her own experiences to the Jews of the Holocaust, even though she herself never experienced what they went through. However, even when taking that into account, her inclusion of Holocaust images greatly enhances the tone and the theme of her poetry and influences the reader greatly.
Rene Suleiman
War has plagued this world since the beginning of time with its skewed glory and honor. From wars of violence and destruction to wars of a more subtle nature they have been raging among civilized society for centuries. Sylvia Plath, the late and decorated poet of the twentieth century, wages her own war with words in her two poems “Daddy” and “The Swarm”. These two poems, containing all the poetic elements that a true poetry connoisseur craves, take the reader through a vivid journey of the horrors of war and its consequences. Through her splendid use of war imagery, Plath not only paints a picture of bloody warfare but also of its combatants; the men who perpetuate it. Sylvia Plath uses war imagery in “Daddy” and “The Swarm” to criticize war and the men who fight them.
Sylvia Plath takes an anti-war stance in her two highly acclaimed poems “Daddy” and “The Swarm” through her use of imagery. Her first poem, although mainly about her relationship with her father, also denounces war with vivid descriptions, “The tongue stuck in my jaw./It stuck in a barb wire snare./I could hardly speak.” (“Daddy” 25-28). Her use of the imagery ‘barbed wire snare’ brings forth a clear picture of the fences that imprison millions during wartime. The ‘snare of war’ illustrated makes Plath mute; she and others cannot speak due to war’s oppressive nature which silences the masses. This description of war’s silencing nature as well as the poem’s overall theme of Nazism casts a highly negative light on warfare. In “The Swarm” she takes a more blatant approach in condemning war, “Somebody is shooting at something in our town--/A dull pom, pom in the Sunday street./Jealousy can open the blood,/It can make black roses./Who are they shooting at?” (“The Swarm” 1-5). This stanza as well as the entire poem carries a more questioning and cynical tone, Plath is stating events and questioning them. The words ‘A dull pom, pom in the Sunday street’ signify gunfire which interrupts the peace of Sunday Sabbath, and her later lines connect jealousy to warfare and bloodshed. Plath also fails to understand the gunfire with the question, ‘Who are they shooting at?’, which communicates the idea that there is no point to war except jealousy and greed, which creates hate instead of love, ‘It can make black roses’. All of these images of war and violence send the message that warfare, created and fought proudly by men, is a terrible occupation.
Sylvia Plath also uses war imagery to castigate the men who fight and begin the wars that she so abhors. In “Daddy” she demonizes men and makes them inhuman, “Every woman adores a Fascist,/The boot in the face, the brute/Brute heart of a brute like you.” (“Daddy” 48-50). While employing sarcasm and vague generalizations with the line, ‘Every woman adores a Fascist’, Plath describes this Fascist as a ‘brute’, an animal with no emotion or human characteristics. In this she is depicting men as beasts of warfare who think and act in ways that only savages could understand. Similarly in “The Swarm” Plath casts light on the absence of sense in men of war, “The dumb, banded bodies/Walking the plank draped with Mother France’s upholstery” (“The Swarm” 47-48). Through this image of men ‘walking the plank’ adorned with spoils of war, Plath shows that while these ‘dumb’ men think that they are moving to victory, in reality they are walking to their death through unnecessary violence. Also her characterization of the men as ‘dumb, banded bodies’ shows soldiers not in a singular glorified light but rather in a pack mentality, that they cannot think for themselves. Through her effective use of war imagery, Plath elucidates her ongoing anti-war sentiment and her disgust with the creators of war.
Even though war is a highly destructive and senseless employment, society continues to perpetuate the idea that war glorifies and adorns men with honor and duty to their country and to their people. In reality, and in the opinion of Sylvia Plath, war destroys and kills innocent lives, makes the men who fight them brainwashed and savage, and is altogether a terrible occupation. Sylvia Plath is not the only person to use creative means to express doubt on warfare; many war veterans jaded with the world have spoken up about the atrocities committed on the battlefield. While society laments the loss of life through violence in wartime, it must also remember that it is the victim of its own creation.
752 words
Kiersten Piekarz
Sylvia Plath was a celebrated confessional poet of her time. Her poetry used both internal and external elements in order to convey a theme. One common image in Plath’s poetry was that of music and sound. In “Two Sisters of Persephone” images of sound are used indirectly to show contrast while in “Morning Song” and “The Swarm” sound images provide for both positive and negative connotations.
First, in the poem “Two Sisters of Persephone” Plath uses sound images to show contrast between the two sisters. For example, “daylong a duet of shade and light” (Persephone 3). The word “duet” alone implies the musical nature, one of two different elements playing off each other to create a whole. In this sentence it shows the stark differences between the two sisters, but also how one cannot exist without the other. The next reference to sound in “Two Sisters of Persephone” is “dry ticks mark time” (Persephone 8) then “hearing ticks blown gold” (Persephone 14). In each line the word “tick” is used as a sound image. When the two tines are compared they each symbolize strictly different concepts of light and dark while they share a common bond of sound. This directly relates to the theme of the poem that no matter what choice a woman makes on sex, she’ll end up in the same place.
Another way Sylvia Plath uses music is to convey both positive and negative messages. An example of how music and sound is used positively is in the poem “Morning Song”; “Your handful of notes/ The clear vowels rise like balloons” (Morning 17-18). Plath wrote this poem to convey her feelings on motherhood and her love and wonder for her child. This was clearly shown through the image of sound. Relating the baby’s cry to vowels and balloons gave the poem a light loving tone. Sylvia Plath then uses sound images negatively in her poem “The Swarm”; “the bees argue, in their black ball,” (Swarm 31). By choosing the word argue to describe the sound of the bees, as well as the sound of gunshot throughout the poem, Plath is able to convey a tone of frustration. These sounds also influence the reader to feel negatively about the subject of the poem. That in turn gives way to the theme of “The Swarm” being about war, and the people caught up in it.
In conclusion, Sylvia Plath’s images of sound and music provide for contrast, negative images, and positive images in her poetry. These all helped to enhance the tone and theme of the poems, and more accurately portray them to the reader.
Warda Nawaz
“The union of two souls”, “infinite bliss”…these are the things people are told when asked about marriage. But in reality, marriage is far from being blissful and successful, as Sylvia Plath points out in many of her poems. This wonderful concept of marriage is shattered when looking carefully at the true meaning behind her words. In the poems “The Applicant” and “Two Sisters of Persephone”, Plath uses injury to show the necessity of getting married and also the pain that comes with it.
First, Plath portrays unmarried couple as broken and worthless. In the opening lines of her poem “The Applicant”, Sylvia is questioning a man about how he feels to be by himself. She almost considers him not human, but something else: “Do you wear a glass eye, false teeth… rubber breasts, [and] stitches to show something’s missing?” (“The Applicant 3, 5-6). All these body parts are shown broken and are replaced with other images that show that the man is very out of place right now. He is pretending to mend himself with stitches, but he is failing because there is no one to look after him. As a result, Plath is making marriage sound like the remedy for all these injuries by saying, “You have a hole, it’s a poultice” (37). A poultice is a heated substance applied on cloth that can pressed to warm a wound or sore. By saying marriage is a “poultice” it is like saying that marriage will warm up, or relieve the wounds the man has. In contrast, Plath is mocking the woman in her other poem by saying, “the wry virgin to the very last, goes graveward, worm-husbanded, yet no woman” (“Two Sisters of Persephone”26-8). The poor woman who decided to stay single and not go through troubles of marriage is found in the grave because she chose not to experience the responsibilities of becoming a wife and a mother. It shows how going against nature’s standards and also societal standards can cause a bad outcome. Because she decided to live by herself, she had a short life and died early because she ignored society’s expectations.
Despite the fact that marriage is illustrated as a solution to the problems they have, Plath also looks down at marriage. She criticizes the responsibilities the wife has in her relationship. In short, Plath is criticizing the role of women in the society and the expectations the societies have of them.. The fact that she will have to “roll away headaches and do whatever you tell it” (“The Applicant” 12) shows that the wife will be responsible for keeping the relationship intact. This means that her role will be that of a stereotypical housewife, but it will be very important one. Plath also uses strong imagery in other poem to describe sex rather painfully. By doing so, she is looking down on it and showing the reality of marriage: “She sees how their red silk flare of petaled blood burns open to the sun’s blade” (“Two Sisters of Persephone” 17-19). Someone outside is looking in and seeing a couple have sex. She observes it as something rather inviting, but also hurtful. Even though flowers are used to describe sex, she is also using other imagery, like blood and blade, which show injury. This is not an appealing experience for a wife. It is carnal, grotesque, and also hurtful. We see the truth of what the woman has to go through to bear a child. The ideal, or the concept of bliss is far gone.
In conclusion, Sylvia Plath shows that marriage is necessary part of life especially because humans are incomplete without it. If not married, both pairs will feel injured and broken. However, marriage itself will not solve all the problems: some of the pain will continue, in particularly for the wife.
Joe Benson
Plath sees the death of her father as a suicide because he could have gotten treatment for his illness but chose not to until it was too late for him to be saved. She sees his death as his exit off the stage of her life, but instead of letting go and moving on, she feels compelled to follow him into his death. She was eight years old when her father died and that was the same year she first attempted to take her own life. In her poem “Daddy” she says, “At twenty I tried to die and get back back back to you.” She is referencing how again at age twenty she tried to take her own life to escape to her father. Plath fails to see that after death there is nothing and that killing herself would be fruitless, but she romanticizes the concept to enhance the themes of death in her writings.
In addition to her overly romantic view of death, she jokes about it as well. In “Lady Lazarus” she writes, “I have done it again. One year in every ten I manage it.” She humors herself by pointing out how every decade she tries to take her own life. Ironically, in “Lady Lazarus” she wrote, “Dying is an art, like everything else, I do it exceptionally well. I do it so it feels like hell. I do it so it feels real.” The irony is that she has attempted suicide twice already and she has not been able to kill herself but she says that she does it exceptionally well. She fails to see the gravity of death and that once she takes one too many pills or lays next to the oven for just one more minute, it will all be over.
Overall Sylvia Plath does not take death seriously. Again in “Lady Lazarus” she says, “I am only 30. And like the cat I have nine times to die.” She thinks she is invincible and that she can attempt suicide seven more time and then die. Unfortunately, Sylvia died on her third attempt when she was only 31. If only she saw that death was not a joke, but truly an end to all things. Maybe then she would still be among the living today.
